WEBVTT

1
00:00:01.660 --> 00:00:05.610
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America,

2
00:00:06.160 --> 00:00:10.080
and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under

3
00:00:10.140 --> 00:00:12.710
God, indivisible, with liberty

4
00:00:13.020 --> 00:00:16.940
and

5
00:00:16.950 --> 00:00:20.200
justice for all.

6
00:00:20.220 --> 00:00:20.600
Thank you.

7
00:00:26.460 --> 00:00:29.500
Welcome to District 12's meeting for May.

8
00:00:30.220 --> 00:00:33.500
If there's anything that's not on our agenda at this time,

9
00:00:34.120 --> 00:00:37.680
please come to the microphone and state your name and address for us,

10
00:00:37.760 --> 00:00:38.200
please.

11
00:00:43.280 --> 00:00:44.080
Can you hear me?

12
00:00:44.960 --> 00:00:48.120
Is this okay? Can you hear me now? My name's Roberta Kirby.

13
00:00:48.180 --> 00:00:52.160
My address is 5886 Woodstock Way, and here's the great news for

14
00:00:52.240 --> 00:00:54.980
everybody. You're going to love this. This is my last time because I give up.

15
00:00:55.620 --> 00:00:59.089
I give up. I have a small list of things that I want to make sure is said, and

16
00:00:59.440 --> 00:01:03.000
personally, I just give up. I did meet with

17
00:01:04.080 --> 00:01:05.240
Carrie and

18
00:01:06.360 --> 00:01:06.720
Pam,

19
00:01:08.700 --> 00:01:12.520
and I did get some paperwork, and when reading through the paperwork, it

20
00:01:12.840 --> 00:01:16.780
became very interesting to me that apparently they went to Finney to

21
00:01:16.820 --> 00:01:20.400
find out some dirt about me, and they found some people

22
00:01:20.940 --> 00:01:24.420
to say stuff, and I got paperwork of negative stuff about

23
00:01:24.480 --> 00:01:28.280
me. One thing was dated sometime in 2021.

24
00:01:30.000 --> 00:01:33.450
And what you wound up doing was instead of solving a problem with

25
00:01:33.600 --> 00:01:37.350
one person, now I have a target on my back.

26
00:01:37.460 --> 00:01:39.660
So I don't feel safe at Finney at all.

27
00:01:39.680 --> 00:01:41.780
But that's not really what I'm complaining about.

28
00:01:41.800 --> 00:01:45.060
What you did put in writing is slander and defamation of character, but that's not

29
00:01:45.080 --> 00:01:48.600
what I'm worried about. What I'm worried about is that everything I have said to

30
00:01:48.640 --> 00:01:52.360
you, Carrie, has been under the American with Disabilities Act,

31
00:01:52.880 --> 00:01:56.500
and there's nothing in this paperwork that says that I am

32
00:01:56.580 --> 00:01:59.820
complaining to you under the American with Disabilities Act.

33
00:02:00.160 --> 00:02:03.620
It's not an employee-customer problem.

34
00:02:04.160 --> 00:02:06.720
I am coming to you under the American with Disabilities Act.

35
00:02:06.760 --> 00:02:10.539
Now, when I came to you with the problem I had with the

36
00:02:10.581 --> 00:02:12.400
woman at the front gate at Finney,

37
00:02:13.400 --> 00:02:17.220
I was told you were the American with Disabilities Department. Is that correct?

38
00:02:17.440 --> 00:02:17.660
Yes.

39
00:02:19.420 --> 00:02:23.340
Is there American Disabilities Department in the building that I saw

40
00:02:23.420 --> 00:02:24.140
you and Pam in?

41
00:02:25.400 --> 00:02:29.160
We don't have a department. I am the Americans with Disability Act-

42
00:02:31.520 --> 00:02:32.220
Representative

43
00:02:33.020 --> 00:02:33.049
... representative.

44
00:02:33.080 --> 00:02:36.680
Okay. Did you know that as the representative, your building does not

45
00:02:36.760 --> 00:02:39.340
have a button for handicap door opening?

46
00:02:40.420 --> 00:02:43.980
Which is not required under the ADA, but yes, I do, and it is on order.

47
00:02:44.040 --> 00:02:47.740
Okay. I would like just one more thing, and I will leave you alone because I give

48
00:02:47.840 --> 00:02:51.520
up. What happened is you created your own narrative.

49
00:02:51.560 --> 00:02:55.400
Not you, whoever wrote the paperwork and stuff, they created their own

50
00:02:55.440 --> 00:02:59.240
narrative and completely kept out what I was saying.

51
00:02:59.620 --> 00:03:03.360
On one piece of paper where the guy tells me off, it says that

52
00:03:03.820 --> 00:03:07.640
I was laying in wait for him. No, I was walking a friend's dog, and

53
00:03:07.700 --> 00:03:11.570
I had to catch my breath in her golf cart. I wasn't laying in wait for anyone.

54
00:03:12.300 --> 00:03:16.060
I just want something that says that I have come to you under the American with

55
00:03:16.100 --> 00:03:20.000
Disabilities Act, not just a complaint against an

56
00:03:20.060 --> 00:03:22.400
employee, not problems that I have.

57
00:03:22.780 --> 00:03:26.060
I am coming to you under the American with Disabilities Act.

58
00:03:26.080 --> 00:03:29.500
And I also need to know how to get copies of recording for

59
00:03:30.520 --> 00:03:31.780
January, February,

60
00:03:33.720 --> 00:03:34.600
April, and May.

61
00:03:36.820 --> 00:03:40.060
And I'm done. That's it. I'm done. Can you tell me how I can do that?

62
00:03:40.140 --> 00:03:40.640
Yeah.

63
00:03:41.840 --> 00:03:45.780
To get copies of the recordings of the meetings, you just go to the District 12

64
00:03:45.840 --> 00:03:49.480
website, and based on the meeting agenda date, there's

65
00:03:49.500 --> 00:03:51.840
a link that says Meeting Media.

66
00:03:51.880 --> 00:03:55.080
Okay. Could someone send me that information? Because I'm not that smart.

67
00:03:55.820 --> 00:03:57.600
Yes. If you provide your information to Ms.

68
00:03:57.660 --> 00:03:58.360
Harris, then

69
00:03:59.180 --> 00:04:02.400
her office is the one that is responsible for public records, and she'll provide

70
00:04:02.440 --> 00:04:03.020
you with the links.

71
00:04:03.440 --> 00:04:05.920
Thank you very much. It's been a delight. You'll never see me again.

72
00:04:07.000 --> 00:04:07.420
Thank you.

73
00:04:10.240 --> 00:04:13.100
Any other comments from the audience at this time?

74
00:04:15.040 --> 00:04:15.680
Moving on.

75
00:04:16.601 --> 00:04:19.839
Law enforcement.

76
00:04:23.560 --> 00:04:25.860
Good afternoon. Captain Kinderwald with police department.

77
00:04:27.040 --> 00:04:30.920
Last week, obviously, we assisted with the President of the United States

78
00:04:30.940 --> 00:04:34.440
arriving. We worked with Secret Service and other law enforcement

79
00:04:34.520 --> 00:04:38.200
agencies to ensure that it was a safe event for all parties involved.

80
00:04:39.880 --> 00:04:43.720
We're pleased to say that he arrived safely, left safely, and there was no

81
00:04:43.800 --> 00:04:44.280
issues.

82
00:04:46.060 --> 00:04:48.560
Other than that, we do have events that are coming up.

83
00:04:48.680 --> 00:04:50.820
They're several months in the future.

84
00:04:51.260 --> 00:04:53.280
We'll be sure to keep you guys updated.

85
00:04:53.680 --> 00:04:55.880
I have no other updates at this point.

86
00:04:57.120 --> 00:04:58.260
Any questions from the board?

87
00:04:59.380 --> 00:04:59.390
No.

88
00:04:59.420 --> 00:04:59.740
Thank you.

89
00:05:00.000 --> 00:05:00.410
All right. Thank you.

90
00:05:00.410 --> 00:05:00.500
Thank you.

91
00:05:04.340 --> 00:05:06.080
Moving on. Consent agenda.

92
00:05:07.520 --> 00:05:10.160
Any questions from the board at this time on the consent agenda?

93
00:05:12.320 --> 00:05:14.300
I do. I have one. Just one quick one.

94
00:05:14.600 --> 00:05:14.760
Okay.

95
00:05:15.600 --> 00:05:16.979
The item that we're going to be...

96
00:05:18.920 --> 00:05:19.260
The

97
00:05:20.560 --> 00:05:24.080
compliance rules are going to be

98
00:05:24.300 --> 00:05:27.580
published and commented on. I just

99
00:05:28.820 --> 00:05:31.120
have one question on that thing for counsel.

100
00:05:31.160 --> 00:05:32.760
He doesn't have to answer it right now.

101
00:05:32.830 --> 00:05:33.560
Can you just speak into the mic?

102
00:05:33.580 --> 00:05:35.060
But as I was going through it-

103
00:05:35.680 --> 00:05:37.680
Mr. Montalvo, could you please speak into your mic?

104
00:05:37.700 --> 00:05:38.160
Oh, I'm sorry.

105
00:05:39.060 --> 00:05:40.140
Got it. Hello?

106
00:05:40.880 --> 00:05:41.320
There you go.

107
00:05:41.680 --> 00:05:41.840
See?

108
00:05:42.020 --> 00:05:42.750
Oh, teared up.

109
00:05:43.520 --> 00:05:46.840
I tore up the socks. Okay. No,

110
00:05:47.800 --> 00:05:51.020
with respect to the proposed changes that are going to be made, and that's fine,

111
00:05:51.060 --> 00:05:53.460
we'll go through that process, but I did have one question,

112
00:05:54.860 --> 00:05:58.340
and perhaps we can have some answer, maybe not today.

113
00:06:00.280 --> 00:06:01.400
Specifically about the

114
00:06:02.300 --> 00:06:04.040
flag displays,

115
00:06:06.520 --> 00:06:10.364
which is beingAs I can tell,

116
00:06:10.524 --> 00:06:13.424
patterned after the statute.

117
00:06:13.504 --> 00:06:16.684
That's 720 statute.

118
00:06:18.384 --> 00:06:21.504
But it is unclear to me at least, and maybe we can

119
00:06:22.144 --> 00:06:25.724
address this at some point in time, whether the

120
00:06:26.124 --> 00:06:30.084
official flags that are permitted to be flown

121
00:06:31.484 --> 00:06:32.124
include

122
00:06:33.004 --> 00:06:36.904
or exclude political flags on temporary poles.

123
00:06:38.164 --> 00:06:40.324
It's not clear to me as I read.

124
00:06:41.184 --> 00:06:45.144
I went back to look at the statute, and I looked at the proposed

125
00:06:45.444 --> 00:06:46.084
rule change,

126
00:06:47.064 --> 00:06:49.664
and there seems to be a little conflict there.

127
00:06:49.704 --> 00:06:51.084
Maybe you can clarify it for me.

128
00:06:53.024 --> 00:06:54.684
Hello. Matt Armstrong, Community Standards.

129
00:06:54.944 --> 00:06:55.224
So

130
00:06:56.024 --> 00:06:59.764
working with legal counsel, district admin, it was brought to our

131
00:06:59.784 --> 00:07:03.494
attention from another board about this particular statute, and we reviewed it all

132
00:07:03.544 --> 00:07:07.164
together. So this particular statute says that you're allowed to have a temporary

133
00:07:07.244 --> 00:07:11.104
flagpole on your property that displays an official American flag,

134
00:07:11.744 --> 00:07:15.514
state of Florida flag, the military branches, or first responders

135
00:07:15.604 --> 00:07:18.864
flag. Your ARC manual already allowed with architectural

136
00:07:18.884 --> 00:07:22.464
approval to have a permanent flagpole not to

137
00:07:22.504 --> 00:07:22.964
exceed-

138
00:07:23.144 --> 00:07:23.364
Correct

139
00:07:23.384 --> 00:07:25.984
... 20 feet in height. We're going to change from 22 to 20 feet.

140
00:07:26.004 --> 00:07:27.804
Yeah, the statute provides 20. Yeah.

141
00:07:28.334 --> 00:07:31.564
Yeah. And then we allow for one flagpole on your home.

142
00:07:32.064 --> 00:07:34.384
Those are two content neutral flagpoles.

143
00:07:34.424 --> 00:07:34.434
Correct.

144
00:07:34.434 --> 00:07:37.824
The statute only governs this temporary one, what has to be

145
00:07:37.944 --> 00:07:41.524
specifically those types of flags, and that's what we would be addressing if there

146
00:07:41.544 --> 00:07:44.284
was something that was outside of what the statute allowed.

147
00:07:44.624 --> 00:07:47.944
Okay, so that would not apply to political flags and stuff like that,

148
00:07:47.964 --> 00:07:51.524
that they'll be flying on a temporary--

149
00:07:51.784 --> 00:07:55.724
If it's on the ARC-approved permanent flagpole, those are

150
00:07:55.764 --> 00:07:57.584
allowed. We're content neutral with that one.

151
00:07:57.724 --> 00:07:57.734
Okay.

152
00:07:57.734 --> 00:07:59.464
The one on the house, we're content neutral.

153
00:08:00.064 --> 00:08:03.624
That temporary one under the statute would only be the American flag,

154
00:08:03.924 --> 00:08:07.644
the state of Florida flag, service flags, or the first responders flags.

155
00:08:08.604 --> 00:08:08.964
Okay.

156
00:08:10.924 --> 00:08:11.124
So

157
00:08:12.284 --> 00:08:15.834
if I want to fly a flag for a political

158
00:08:16.004 --> 00:08:16.524
candidate,

159
00:08:17.784 --> 00:08:19.583
would that be permissible under this rule?

160
00:08:20.284 --> 00:08:21.504
On your house?

161
00:08:21.724 --> 00:08:21.904
Yes.

162
00:08:22.304 --> 00:08:22.364
An

163
00:08:23.384 --> 00:08:24.084
ARC-approved one?

164
00:08:25.524 --> 00:08:26.124
Not on this.

165
00:08:27.164 --> 00:08:31.004
So the answer is yes. You can, as you've always been able to,

166
00:08:31.224 --> 00:08:35.004
you can either have an approved flagpole, you can fly any type of flag on it,

167
00:08:35.504 --> 00:08:38.465
or you can fly any type of flag attached to your home.

168
00:08:38.644 --> 00:08:38.874
Correct.

169
00:08:38.874 --> 00:08:42.324
If you want an additional portable flag, it has to

170
00:08:42.404 --> 00:08:44.384
be per this requirement.

171
00:08:44.744 --> 00:08:48.564
Okay. So that was the question that was raised in my

172
00:08:48.644 --> 00:08:52.304
mind. So nothing really changes is what you're saying. Okay.

173
00:08:52.784 --> 00:08:53.104
Thank you.

174
00:08:57.304 --> 00:08:58.184
Any other comments

175
00:08:59.264 --> 00:09:00.804
from the board? Do I have a motion?

176
00:09:00.984 --> 00:09:03.704
Move to approve the consent agenda.

177
00:09:04.024 --> 00:09:04.324
Second.

178
00:09:04.664 --> 00:09:05.724
Second. All in favor?

179
00:09:06.004 --> 00:09:06.204
Aye.

180
00:09:06.264 --> 00:09:06.604
Aye.

181
00:09:06.704 --> 00:09:08.044
Aye. Moving on.

182
00:09:08.844 --> 00:09:12.164
Yes, sir. Ms. Karen Clary is going to be giving you your

183
00:09:12.364 --> 00:09:16.244
2026, 2027 budget review. This is,

184
00:09:16.384 --> 00:09:19.324
as you're aware, one of the first times that we're introducing your

185
00:09:19.384 --> 00:09:23.224
upcoming year budget. So we'll go through this and

186
00:09:23.264 --> 00:09:25.804
then we'll be happy to answer any questions you may have.

187
00:09:26.884 --> 00:09:30.574
Thank you, Carrie. Good afternoon, board. Karen Clary, assistant budget director.

188
00:09:31.104 --> 00:09:34.824
I'm here today to review the District 12 recommended budget for fiscal year

189
00:09:34.834 --> 00:09:37.344
'26, '27, as prepared by staff.

190
00:09:38.584 --> 00:09:42.064
First, we're going to look at your revenue comparison from fiscal year '25,

191
00:09:42.174 --> 00:09:45.884
'26 amended budget. As you can see, we've kept your maintenance

192
00:09:45.944 --> 00:09:48.634
assessments at the same rate, which would be a 0% increase.

193
00:09:49.144 --> 00:09:52.194
Your interest income does have a moderate decrease of

194
00:09:52.224 --> 00:09:56.034
$46,000, or 28%. This is based on

195
00:09:56.064 --> 00:09:59.644
current market projections, which are down based on performance as of today.

196
00:10:00.684 --> 00:10:02.604
Your use of general R&amp;R funds is at

197
00:10:02.614 --> 00:10:06.604
$42,444, which is a decrease in

198
00:10:06.684 --> 00:10:10.184
fiscal year '25, '26 usage of just under

199
00:10:10.194 --> 00:10:14.164
$80,000. Fiscal year '26, '27 also sees

200
00:10:14.244 --> 00:10:18.153
usage in your working capital of just over $105,000,

201
00:10:18.264 --> 00:10:22.184
which is a swing from last year's edition of about $75,000.

202
00:10:24.104 --> 00:10:27.973
As you can see from this pie chart, your project-wide fees make up just over half

203
00:10:28.024 --> 00:10:31.394
of your overall appropriations. Repairs and maintenance are budgeted at

204
00:10:31.394 --> 00:10:34.254
$1.3 million, and professional services are at

205
00:10:34.254 --> 00:10:38.204
$486,000. Both categories see an increase

206
00:10:38.244 --> 00:10:41.904
from fiscal year '25, '26. Utility services and

207
00:10:42.004 --> 00:10:45.704
personnel and miscellaneous operating expenditures round out your budget at

208
00:10:45.724 --> 00:10:49.024
$138,000 and $31,000,

209
00:10:49.074 --> 00:10:49.774
respectively.

210
00:10:51.154 --> 00:10:54.824
In comparison to fiscal year '25, '26, you can see that most

211
00:10:54.864 --> 00:10:58.614
expenditure categories saw minimal increases apart from professional

212
00:10:58.664 --> 00:11:01.374
services, which did see a decrease of about

213
00:11:01.374 --> 00:11:05.244
$22,000 or 4%. Overall, we see an

214
00:11:05.284 --> 00:11:07.604
increase in your budgeted appropriations of

215
00:11:07.614 --> 00:11:11.444
$96,816 or 2%

216
00:11:11.484 --> 00:11:12.664
from the current fiscal year.

217
00:11:14.684 --> 00:11:18.084
Moving on, we've highlighted some of your fiscal year '26, '27

218
00:11:18.144 --> 00:11:21.764
appropriation variances. Your building and structure maintenance sees an

219
00:11:21.824 --> 00:11:25.793
increase of 26,500, or 84%, based on

220
00:11:25.824 --> 00:11:29.764
the Villa lighting project schedule and increased fence repairs for fiscal

221
00:11:29.784 --> 00:11:33.774
year '26, '27. A $19,000 increase in other

222
00:11:33.844 --> 00:11:37.724
maintenance can be attributed to contract expirations and funding requirements

223
00:11:37.804 --> 00:11:41.504
for biannual pressure washing. Your project-wide fees increased

224
00:11:41.664 --> 00:11:45.444
2%, which was for all applicable districts in this fiscal year.

225
00:11:47.964 --> 00:11:51.314
Your district's project-wide fees are determined by an allocation based on

226
00:11:51.344 --> 00:11:55.044
assessable acreage, which is the same methodology used for annual maintenance

227
00:11:55.104 --> 00:11:56.834
assessments and bond assessments.

228
00:11:57.314 --> 00:12:00.744
This allocation spreads the cost of and the risk to

229
00:12:00.804 --> 00:12:04.534
infrastructure and facilities that benefit all residents within the Sumter Landing

230
00:12:04.564 --> 00:12:08.244
Amenity Division. Your assessable acreage remains unchanged at

231
00:12:08.444 --> 00:12:11.844
1,202.95 acres, which represents

232
00:12:11.904 --> 00:12:15.084
11.1% of the overall project-wide fund.

233
00:12:15.824 --> 00:12:19.454
Based on this, the fiscal year '26, '27 recommended budget for your

234
00:12:19.724 --> 00:12:21.464
portion of project-wide fees is

235
00:12:21.474 --> 00:12:24.844
$2,361,665

236
00:12:25.344 --> 00:12:28.464
or, as I said earlier, a 2% increase over last fiscal

237
00:12:28.524 --> 00:12:32.294
year.This 2% increase reflects the current

238
00:12:32.314 --> 00:12:36.144
projection for contributions to the project-wide fund and is mainly driven by

239
00:12:36.174 --> 00:12:40.114
capital improvement planning, which includes items like fencing, multimodal

240
00:12:40.194 --> 00:12:43.854
path mill and overlay, and other improvements, such as pump stations and entry

241
00:12:43.934 --> 00:12:47.914
features. The project-wide budget also accounts for expected cost

242
00:12:47.954 --> 00:12:51.434
increase tied to contract renewals and general inflation for operating

243
00:12:51.514 --> 00:12:52.094
purposes.

244
00:12:52.934 --> 00:12:56.094
For the current fiscal year, the capital improvement plan totals about

245
00:12:56.104 --> 00:12:59.774
$1.05 million, but increases to approximately

246
00:12:59.784 --> 00:13:03.354
$1.77 million in fiscal year '26-'27.

247
00:13:04.074 --> 00:13:07.814
After that, costs are expected to level off with projections of around

248
00:13:07.834 --> 00:13:11.174
$350,000 in fiscal year '27-'28,

249
00:13:11.443 --> 00:13:15.214
$322,000 in fiscal year '28-'29, and

250
00:13:15.224 --> 00:13:18.394
$980,000 in fiscal year '30-'31.

251
00:13:19.214 --> 00:13:23.094
Much of the fiscal year '26-'27 spending is related to fence replacement

252
00:13:23.174 --> 00:13:27.154
projects, followed by work on multimodal path resurfacing and the repainting

253
00:13:27.214 --> 00:13:28.474
of some entry features.

254
00:13:31.174 --> 00:13:34.614
Looking at your five-year budget estimate for revenues, we're keeping your

255
00:13:34.654 --> 00:13:37.554
maintenance assessments steady at just over $4

256
00:13:37.574 --> 00:13:41.554
million. Due to the uncertainty of the market currently, we have kept your

257
00:13:41.574 --> 00:13:44.154
budgeted interest income flat for all five years.

258
00:13:44.994 --> 00:13:48.294
Based on current projections, you are budgeted to utilize approximately

259
00:13:48.304 --> 00:13:52.054
$1.4 million of your working capital over this five-year

260
00:13:52.154 --> 00:13:56.034
period, with a steadily increasing year-over-year usage through fiscal year

261
00:13:56.094 --> 00:13:56.954
'30-'31.

262
00:13:57.754 --> 00:14:01.614
Fiscal year '26-'27 also includes utilization of approximately

263
00:14:01.624 --> 00:14:04.424
$42,000 of your general reserve funds.

264
00:14:07.474 --> 00:14:11.134
Moving on. Next, we'll review your five-year budgeted appropriations.

265
00:14:11.424 --> 00:14:15.134
Personnel and miscellaneous operating stays fairly steady through fiscal year

266
00:14:15.144 --> 00:14:19.074
'30-'31, with minimal fluctuations due to pricing for casualty

267
00:14:19.114 --> 00:14:22.694
and liability insurance and our legal advertising process.

268
00:14:22.734 --> 00:14:26.214
Professional services, utility services, and the repairs and maintenance

269
00:14:26.254 --> 00:14:29.914
category all see incremental increases year over year based on

270
00:14:29.994 --> 00:14:33.354
contract pricing, maintenance schedules, and projected utilization.

271
00:14:34.194 --> 00:14:37.894
Finally, your project-wide fees are currently budgeted to increase 2%

272
00:14:37.954 --> 00:14:40.194
annually through fiscal year '30-'31.

273
00:14:42.514 --> 00:14:46.314
With the annual utilization of your working capital, we are projected to draw

274
00:14:46.374 --> 00:14:50.114
down your fund balance approximately $1.5 million between

275
00:14:50.194 --> 00:14:53.494
fiscal year '26-'27 and fiscal year '30-'31.

276
00:14:54.394 --> 00:14:57.234
Currently, the only planned expenditure for your reserve fund is the

277
00:14:57.244 --> 00:15:00.874
$42,000 previously mentioned related to multimodal path

278
00:15:00.914 --> 00:15:04.694
rejuvenator. And at the end of fiscal year '30-'31, your fund balance is

279
00:15:04.754 --> 00:15:08.314
currently projected to be just shy of $3.2 million.

280
00:15:10.414 --> 00:15:13.874
Your target reserve policy, established in July of 2024,

281
00:15:13.974 --> 00:15:17.774
requires the district to maintain a minimum combined unassigned and committed cash

282
00:15:17.814 --> 00:15:21.684
reserve balance equal to 35% of revenues, plus four months of annual

283
00:15:21.734 --> 00:15:25.644
operating expenses. As you can see, you are projected to exceed this

284
00:15:25.674 --> 00:15:29.254
target over the five-year period in spite of the use of working capital that we

285
00:15:29.354 --> 00:15:30.144
discussed earlier.

286
00:15:32.684 --> 00:15:36.384
Looking at your fund balance forecast, we see that your expenditures are projected

287
00:15:36.414 --> 00:15:40.114
to outpace your revenues on an annual basis, prompting that decline in fund

288
00:15:40.194 --> 00:15:43.574
balance. Making sure your operating expenses are covered by your

289
00:15:43.674 --> 00:15:47.494
operating revenues on an annual basis is necessary to keep the district on

290
00:15:47.594 --> 00:15:50.994
stable financial ground. And as you can see, your fund balance does decline

291
00:15:51.074 --> 00:15:53.074
steadily through fiscal year '30-'31.

292
00:15:55.614 --> 00:15:59.474
Although there is no current recommendation for a maintenance assessment increase

293
00:15:59.494 --> 00:16:03.034
in the five-year budget, we did want to provide some information should it be

294
00:16:03.094 --> 00:16:05.614
necessary to perform an increase in these out years.

295
00:16:06.094 --> 00:16:09.914
With your current maintenance assessment rate, a 1% increase would

296
00:16:09.994 --> 00:16:13.574
garner an additional $40,412 in revenue.

297
00:16:14.194 --> 00:16:18.174
You would have an additional $842 in tax collector fees and about

298
00:16:18.234 --> 00:16:21.624
$5,000 in other expenses related to the increases.

299
00:16:22.574 --> 00:16:26.443
Each 1% increase in the rate would have an average annual household impact of

300
00:16:26.454 --> 00:16:30.014
approximately $6. So basically, for every 1%

301
00:16:30.074 --> 00:16:33.514
increase to your current rates, residents could expect to see around a $6

302
00:16:33.954 --> 00:16:36.704
increase in their annual maintenance assessment charge.

303
00:16:37.194 --> 00:16:40.114
Just as a reminder, this is the annual maintenance assessment that's on your

304
00:16:40.154 --> 00:16:43.214
Sumpter County tax bill and not an increase to your monthly amenity

305
00:16:43.294 --> 00:16:44.714
charges.

306
00:16:45.534 --> 00:16:48.874
At this time, we're requesting the board give staff direction for your maintenance

307
00:16:48.934 --> 00:16:52.374
assessments, even if that direction is to keep them flat with no increase.

308
00:16:52.814 --> 00:16:56.614
Please keep in mind, when you adopt your proposed budget in June, no further

309
00:16:56.754 --> 00:16:59.874
increases can be made to your maintenance assessment rates.

310
00:16:59.894 --> 00:17:03.494
That preliminary approval will include your maximum your maintenance

311
00:17:03.534 --> 00:17:07.154
assessment rates can be set at, though you can decide on a lower rate prior to

312
00:17:07.254 --> 00:17:08.734
final adoption in September.

313
00:17:10.154 --> 00:17:13.315
And at that, I'll give you the floor.

314
00:17:13.354 --> 00:17:13.643
Mm-hmm.

315
00:17:15.994 --> 00:17:18.335
Any questions from the board at this time?

316
00:17:20.055 --> 00:17:21.854
Mm-mm. No.

317
00:17:24.354 --> 00:17:28.315
So, Mr. Chair, we just need direction from the board if you

318
00:17:28.354 --> 00:17:31.714
are going to accept staff's recommendation and not do a maintenance assessment

319
00:17:31.774 --> 00:17:35.744
increase this next year. If so, then we will present your preliminary

320
00:17:35.814 --> 00:17:39.594
budget to you in June. And as Ms. Cleary stated, once you approve that

321
00:17:39.654 --> 00:17:43.554
preliminary budget, you cannot, at a later date, decide that you

322
00:17:43.574 --> 00:17:47.134
would then like to increase and have an increase to your maintenance assessments.

323
00:17:48.174 --> 00:17:50.854
I would still like to have just a reserve

324
00:17:51.714 --> 00:17:55.254
of 1% added into it, so we can always change our

325
00:17:55.294 --> 00:17:57.234
mind when it comes to the vote.

326
00:17:57.574 --> 00:17:59.054
Mm-hmm. Can we change it upward?

327
00:18:00.174 --> 00:18:01.554
No, you can only change it down.

328
00:18:01.754 --> 00:18:01.934
Down.

329
00:18:02.014 --> 00:18:05.994
So keep in mind, if you put in that there's going to be a

330
00:18:06.154 --> 00:18:06.874
1%

331
00:18:09.414 --> 00:18:13.214
maintenance assessment increase, then if you approve that in June, that's

332
00:18:13.274 --> 00:18:13.994
when the

333
00:18:14.894 --> 00:18:17.374
letters and notices go out to all of the property owners.

334
00:18:18.614 --> 00:18:18.794
Mm-hmm.

335
00:18:20.754 --> 00:18:24.474
But we can certainly include it for information so you can see what that does to

336
00:18:24.514 --> 00:18:26.514
your five-year fund balance outlook.

337
00:18:26.754 --> 00:18:27.654
That's what I would like.

338
00:18:27.814 --> 00:18:27.844
Mm-hmm.

339
00:18:27.874 --> 00:18:30.566
To have it for the five-year outlookAt this time?

340
00:18:31.226 --> 00:18:31.616
Yep. Agree.

341
00:18:31.646 --> 00:18:34.526
Would we just like to see the 1% this year?

342
00:18:34.896 --> 00:18:34.896
Right.

343
00:18:34.906 --> 00:18:35.806
What that does? Okay.

344
00:18:35.986 --> 00:18:36.015
Yeah.

345
00:18:36.015 --> 00:18:39.286
Yeah, we can absolutely bring that to the June proposed.

346
00:18:40.966 --> 00:18:44.526
If we can't change that before June,

347
00:18:45.206 --> 00:18:46.966
I'm concerned about the 1%.

348
00:18:49.526 --> 00:18:53.026
Last year, we had to raise the assessment by 4%,

349
00:18:54.366 --> 00:18:57.346
and I think that shows our lack of

350
00:18:58.846 --> 00:19:02.686
pre-thinking on... It's a bigger number than I like to see,

351
00:19:03.886 --> 00:19:07.486
particularly since it exceeded inflation by almost a full percent.

352
00:19:08.946 --> 00:19:12.666
I would like to see the projection at this point to be 2%,

353
00:19:12.786 --> 00:19:13.626
which can be lowered,

354
00:19:16.646 --> 00:19:20.606
but having it at 1% and locking us into

355
00:19:20.666 --> 00:19:21.406
that, essentially-

356
00:19:22.126 --> 00:19:25.926
We can provide both options. We can bring back flat 1% and

357
00:19:26.086 --> 00:19:29.486
2% in June so you can see how all three compare to each other.

358
00:19:29.586 --> 00:19:33.566
I'd like to see 2%. I don't want to see 4% next year because

359
00:19:33.626 --> 00:19:34.925
we only do 1% this year.

360
00:19:35.246 --> 00:19:35.466
Yeah.

361
00:19:35.546 --> 00:19:36.066
Absolutely.

362
00:19:36.106 --> 00:19:40.086
And right now, the numbers look like we can't get there

363
00:19:40.126 --> 00:19:40.486
from here.

364
00:19:40.766 --> 00:19:42.706
And we can bring that. The only thing that we

365
00:19:43.786 --> 00:19:47.486
sometimes do a 3% or a 4% instead of the lower is just

366
00:19:47.526 --> 00:19:49.406
because there is a cost associated with it.

367
00:19:49.416 --> 00:19:49.416
Yeah.

368
00:19:49.426 --> 00:19:51.666
And if we do 1% every year, you have-

369
00:19:51.706 --> 00:19:51.886
Right

370
00:19:51.946 --> 00:19:52.786
... those costs every year.

371
00:19:53.106 --> 00:19:53.206
Yeah.

372
00:19:53.546 --> 00:19:55.866
But absolutely, we can prepare that and bring that back to you.

373
00:19:55.926 --> 00:19:57.166
Yeah, I understand that.

374
00:19:58.946 --> 00:20:00.126
Board in favor of that?

375
00:20:00.186 --> 00:20:02.416
Sure, yes. Good idea.

376
00:20:02.726 --> 00:20:03.706
Do I have a motion for that?

377
00:20:04.146 --> 00:20:04.646
I so move.

378
00:20:05.406 --> 00:20:05.666
Second?

379
00:20:06.256 --> 00:20:06.256
Second.

380
00:20:07.266 --> 00:20:07.846
All in favor?

381
00:20:08.346 --> 00:20:08.546
Aye.

382
00:20:08.586 --> 00:20:09.106
Aye.

383
00:20:09.466 --> 00:20:09.766
Thank you.

384
00:20:10.006 --> 00:20:11.526
We have a couple more slides. I'm sorry.

385
00:20:11.966 --> 00:20:12.166
Thank you.

386
00:20:12.206 --> 00:20:15.786
The setup is a little strange. Finally, we have your debt service funds.

387
00:20:15.926 --> 00:20:19.346
Looking at the three phases of your debt service fund, they are meeting the

388
00:20:19.406 --> 00:20:22.926
amortization schedules and have healthy reserve balances at this time.

389
00:20:23.746 --> 00:20:27.286
As a reminder, we'll come back to your June 8th regular meeting to be held

390
00:20:27.386 --> 00:20:31.206
here at Everglades Recreation Center at 1:00 PM to review and approve your

391
00:20:31.246 --> 00:20:34.406
fiscal year '26, '27 proposed budget as discussed.

392
00:20:34.836 --> 00:20:36.486
And if there's any questions, we're here to answer them.

393
00:20:38.886 --> 00:20:40.046
Any other questions?

394
00:20:40.146 --> 00:20:43.906
I just have one question, and I did it in the other meeting this morning as

395
00:20:43.986 --> 00:20:44.266
well.

396
00:20:45.746 --> 00:20:49.606
I couldn't remember when we did the 4%, but you're saying we did it last

397
00:20:49.646 --> 00:20:52.966
year. And I thought at that time that was going to

398
00:20:53.706 --> 00:20:54.646
carry us for a while.

399
00:20:55.646 --> 00:20:58.566
So I guess I'm asking, and you don't necessarily have to do it today, and I

400
00:20:59.086 --> 00:20:59.626
personally

401
00:21:00.606 --> 00:21:02.966
have not been able to go through this line by line, but

402
00:21:05.666 --> 00:21:08.926
I would like to know what's reared its head to make this

403
00:21:10.386 --> 00:21:12.886
be different than what we talked about last year.

404
00:21:15.286 --> 00:21:15.986
Go.

405
00:21:16.386 --> 00:21:20.146
And I guess my big concern is, does it have anything to do

406
00:21:20.166 --> 00:21:21.926
with amenity ownership?

407
00:21:23.226 --> 00:21:23.336
Because-

408
00:21:23.386 --> 00:21:23.566
So,

409
00:21:25.246 --> 00:21:29.186
if you look there for your fund balance, you are in a

410
00:21:29.226 --> 00:21:31.026
very healthy position.

411
00:21:31.176 --> 00:21:31.326
Mm-hmm.

412
00:21:31.446 --> 00:21:35.306
There is absolutely no reason that you have to do a

413
00:21:35.346 --> 00:21:39.006
maintenance assessment increase this year, next year, or even in three years.

414
00:21:39.646 --> 00:21:42.306
Your target reserve, if you'll go to the next slide,

415
00:21:43.506 --> 00:21:47.146
shows that your target of what you should have in reserves is

416
00:21:47.246 --> 00:21:50.666
at a certain amount. And up until-

417
00:21:51.646 --> 00:21:52.306
31

418
00:21:52.316 --> 00:21:56.306
... '29, '30, you don't even dip under a million above

419
00:21:56.366 --> 00:22:00.306
what your reserves are. So you are not in a state where

420
00:22:00.566 --> 00:22:02.746
we are telling you that you should have an increase.

421
00:22:02.946 --> 00:22:06.896
Now, if you want to not see that fund balance dip as

422
00:22:06.946 --> 00:22:10.646
much as it is, then you may want to look at doing a percentage

423
00:22:10.686 --> 00:22:14.566
increase sooner than five years. But certainly, we

424
00:22:14.606 --> 00:22:16.655
will show you what it looks like at a 2%.

425
00:22:16.886 --> 00:22:16.896
Okay.

426
00:22:16.926 --> 00:22:20.626
But there is no reason that you need to have a maintenance assessment

427
00:22:20.646 --> 00:22:21.406
increase this year.

428
00:22:21.706 --> 00:22:25.526
Okay, because right now, that balance is just short of

429
00:22:25.686 --> 00:22:29.546
1.9 million. At the end, our end, '30, '31, it's going to

430
00:22:29.586 --> 00:22:30.846
be 211,000.

431
00:22:30.986 --> 00:22:32.526
That's above your minimum, though.

432
00:22:32.566 --> 00:22:33.106
Above the minimum.

433
00:22:33.146 --> 00:22:33.286
Yes.

434
00:22:33.466 --> 00:22:36.826
But that's money in my left pocket versus-

435
00:22:36.946 --> 00:22:37.086
No

436
00:22:37.106 --> 00:22:37.685
... in my right pocket.

437
00:22:37.866 --> 00:22:41.666
Absolutely. As a minimum, you want to have, I believe

438
00:22:41.706 --> 00:22:44.736
it's 2.9 million in reserves.

439
00:22:44.866 --> 00:22:44.986
Right.

440
00:22:45.766 --> 00:22:49.405
So in year '30, '31, you're going to have...

441
00:22:50.426 --> 00:22:51.376
I can't read it very well.

442
00:22:51.376 --> 00:22:52.986
About 3.2 million total.

443
00:22:54.106 --> 00:22:57.066
So that's still a very healthy place to be.

444
00:22:57.206 --> 00:23:00.806
But I agree, you don't want to get to where in five, six years you're doing a

445
00:23:00.826 --> 00:23:04.666
10% increase. You'd rather do a couple 2% or whatever it

446
00:23:04.706 --> 00:23:08.686
may be. But I think when you look at the 2%, and we can come up with some

447
00:23:08.766 --> 00:23:12.566
options, it may be where you wait another two, three years, then do a

448
00:23:12.706 --> 00:23:16.146
2%, and I think you'll still find that you're in a healthy place.

449
00:23:16.906 --> 00:23:19.416
Oh, and we can kick that around more next June when we have-

450
00:23:19.706 --> 00:23:21.966
Yes. We'll have different options for you to consider.

451
00:23:22.966 --> 00:23:23.266
Thank you.

452
00:23:23.866 --> 00:23:24.186
Thank you.

453
00:23:24.466 --> 00:23:24.826
Thank you.

454
00:23:25.026 --> 00:23:26.686
Thanks. Nice to meet you.

455
00:23:27.006 --> 00:23:28.706
You as well.

456
00:23:34.206 --> 00:23:34.986
Item 4B.

457
00:23:37.946 --> 00:23:40.386
Yes, sir. Mr. Armstrong will present this item.

458
00:23:45.366 --> 00:23:47.476
Hello, board. Matt Armstrong, Director of Community Standards.

459
00:23:47.726 --> 00:23:51.446
So before you today, we do have a resident request to discuss their case, case

460
00:23:51.486 --> 00:23:55.386
number D120825. Property was brought before the

461
00:23:55.406 --> 00:23:59.146
deed compliance hearing officer at a public hearing on August 4th, 2025,

462
00:23:59.306 --> 00:24:02.686
and found to be in violation for modifications not in accordance with an approved

463
00:24:03.046 --> 00:24:06.586
ARC application. They were given 10 days to bring the property into

464
00:24:06.626 --> 00:24:07.326
compliance

465
00:24:08.526 --> 00:24:12.126
or submit for a new ARC application and come into accordance with that

466
00:24:12.186 --> 00:24:15.606
application or bring their property back to original construction.

467
00:24:16.346 --> 00:24:20.046
We have provided an in-depth timeline of the different

468
00:24:20.066 --> 00:24:22.706
occurrences through this process with the homeowners.

469
00:24:23.966 --> 00:24:24.246
On

470
00:24:25.126 --> 00:24:28.856
February 8th, 2026, Southwest Florida Water Management District, also known as

471
00:24:28.886 --> 00:24:32.846
SWFWMD, entered into a phase two drought mandate where all deed

472
00:24:32.866 --> 00:24:36.806
restrictions when it comes to enforcement regarding water had to be temporarily

473
00:24:36.886 --> 00:24:40.846
suspended until July 1st.We are currently

474
00:24:40.906 --> 00:24:42.966
in a holding pattern with the property.

475
00:24:43.026 --> 00:24:44.956
At this time, there's an outstanding fine balance of

476
00:24:44.956 --> 00:24:47.346
$10,601.15.

477
00:24:48.446 --> 00:24:52.246
Of that, it's $2,051.15 in associated costs

478
00:24:52.286 --> 00:24:55.206
incurred by the district. That includes the lien, the public hearing, and the legal

479
00:24:55.246 --> 00:24:59.006
expenses, and this does not include any costs associated with the engineering

480
00:24:59.046 --> 00:25:02.816
services provided by Klemer, Farner, &amp; Barley that you had requested in

481
00:25:02.866 --> 00:25:04.646
reviewing of the properties in question.

482
00:25:04.686 --> 00:25:08.266
So, it is staff's recommendation to have legal counsel

483
00:25:08.506 --> 00:25:11.986
discuss a settlement with the homeowner or deny the homeowner's request to waive

484
00:25:12.106 --> 00:25:14.326
the fines, and the homeowners are here today to discuss this.

485
00:25:16.706 --> 00:25:18.106
Any questions from the board?

486
00:25:22.226 --> 00:25:25.626
No, but I think that it would be wise to have a

487
00:25:25.666 --> 00:25:26.366
discussion.

488
00:25:27.406 --> 00:25:30.146
I'm not prepared to make a absolute

489
00:25:31.066 --> 00:25:31.926
categorical

490
00:25:32.806 --> 00:25:35.006
decision with respect to the fine at this point.

491
00:25:35.426 --> 00:25:38.426
I went through all the history. It took a while.

492
00:25:39.426 --> 00:25:39.846
And

493
00:25:40.746 --> 00:25:41.406
I can see where

494
00:25:42.406 --> 00:25:45.346
things sometimes run sideways and sometimes they come back or whatever.

495
00:25:46.406 --> 00:25:46.666
But

496
00:25:48.086 --> 00:25:50.426
I think that personally, I would like to see counsel

497
00:25:51.246 --> 00:25:53.776
discuss this matter with the property owner

498
00:25:54.666 --> 00:25:57.166
or get a better feel for what can be done, maybe make some

499
00:25:57.206 --> 00:25:59.086
recommendation.

500
00:25:59.126 --> 00:26:02.546
The property owner's here if you want to hear from the property owner.

501
00:26:03.386 --> 00:26:03.926
Do you want us to-

502
00:26:04.166 --> 00:26:04.346
Sure

503
00:26:04.466 --> 00:26:05.216
... depend on-

504
00:26:05.226 --> 00:26:06.806
Yeah, that's fine.

505
00:26:08.286 --> 00:26:10.506
I can handle that the way I've done it in the past.

506
00:26:10.566 --> 00:26:14.046
What I would ask is if the board would direct me to maybe one of the

507
00:26:14.086 --> 00:26:17.616
supervisors, maybe Supervisor Montalvo, who I've dealt with before in resolving

508
00:26:17.646 --> 00:26:19.966
these issues with other property owners to...

509
00:26:21.206 --> 00:26:25.126
I don't like going into these things blind and coming back with some amount

510
00:26:25.146 --> 00:26:27.126
of money just for you guys to reject it.

511
00:26:27.186 --> 00:26:31.086
I'd rather have the ability to talk to one of the supervisors, work

512
00:26:31.126 --> 00:26:33.936
with one of the supervisors. Maybe we can come to some agreement with the property

513
00:26:34.006 --> 00:26:37.266
owner and bring it back to you with a recommendation to approve it.

514
00:26:38.626 --> 00:26:42.006
Yeah, and we have done that before. They work well, and I'll be happy to do that.

515
00:26:42.946 --> 00:26:44.766
That's fine. I'm in agreement with that.

516
00:26:45.446 --> 00:26:45.666
Okay.

517
00:26:45.826 --> 00:26:46.326
No further agreement?

518
00:26:46.866 --> 00:26:48.846
I'll reach out to the property owner.

519
00:26:48.915 --> 00:26:52.746
I'll meet with the property owner, talk to them initially, and then meet with

520
00:26:53.006 --> 00:26:54.726
Supervisor Montalvo and go from there.

521
00:26:55.286 --> 00:26:55.526
All right.

522
00:26:55.826 --> 00:26:56.086
Thank you.

523
00:26:56.726 --> 00:26:57.226
Thank you.

524
00:26:58.486 --> 00:26:58.596
That's great.

525
00:26:58.596 --> 00:26:59.256
Do you want a motion?

526
00:27:02.766 --> 00:27:04.466
Yeah. Why don't we get a motion for option one?

527
00:27:05.166 --> 00:27:07.416
No. Motion. I need a motion for-

528
00:27:07.486 --> 00:27:08.286
I so move.

529
00:27:08.646 --> 00:27:09.106
Second.

530
00:27:09.546 --> 00:27:10.086
All in favor?

531
00:27:10.186 --> 00:27:10.506
For legal counsel.

532
00:27:10.546 --> 00:27:11.606
Aye.

533
00:27:13.006 --> 00:27:13.876
There you go. Thank you.

534
00:27:13.876 --> 00:27:13.986
Thank you.

535
00:27:14.866 --> 00:27:15.146
Yeah.

536
00:27:16.146 --> 00:27:18.766
Probably

537
00:27:18.776 --> 00:27:20.886
tomorrow.

538
00:27:20.946 --> 00:27:26.546
Probably.

539
00:27:26.606 --> 00:27:26.966
Thank you.

540
00:27:29.126 --> 00:27:31.386
Can I make a comment on that?

541
00:27:31.806 --> 00:27:32.126
Yeah.

542
00:27:38.806 --> 00:27:39.346
Good afternoon,

543
00:27:40.226 --> 00:27:43.666
Chairman, board members, staff. My name is John De Fernando,

544
00:27:44.026 --> 00:27:45.246
4546 Perlman Way,

545
00:27:46.146 --> 00:27:49.706
although you might not recognize me without my devil costume.

546
00:27:51.066 --> 00:27:51.596
Apparently,

547
00:27:52.486 --> 00:27:54.206
during the agenda item, there was

548
00:27:55.746 --> 00:27:57.346
issues that were raised.

549
00:27:58.746 --> 00:28:02.686
I'd like to just sort of back up 30,000 feet on this particular issue

550
00:28:02.746 --> 00:28:05.766
before we decide that we should forgive fines.

551
00:28:06.326 --> 00:28:09.086
Many neighbors are here for the sixth board meeting in a row

552
00:28:09.926 --> 00:28:13.086
because we still remain deeply concerned about the swale

553
00:28:13.126 --> 00:28:16.786
modifications on Perlman Way. The email

554
00:28:17.026 --> 00:28:20.506
included in your packet tries to reframe

555
00:28:20.515 --> 00:28:24.326
this whole item as a series of misunderstandings, bad

556
00:28:24.366 --> 00:28:25.966
advice, personal grievances.

557
00:28:26.826 --> 00:28:30.106
But the district's record shows a sustained pattern of choices

558
00:28:31.066 --> 00:28:33.646
that damage the shared stormwater conveyance.

559
00:28:34.766 --> 00:28:38.466
It was a choice to begin construction in 2023 without an ARC plan.

560
00:28:39.446 --> 00:28:43.246
It was a choice to disregard the conditions attached to the ARC plan that was

561
00:28:43.266 --> 00:28:45.746
initially or subsequently granted.

562
00:28:46.786 --> 00:28:50.716
It was a choice to install artificial turf, a sand trap, a buried tank, and

563
00:28:50.726 --> 00:28:54.146
an undersized private drainage system in a platted easement.

564
00:28:54.906 --> 00:28:58.886
It was a choice to tell concerned neighbors that everything was approved by ARC,

565
00:28:59.425 --> 00:29:00.506
nothing to see here.

566
00:29:02.226 --> 00:29:02.906
Please move on.

567
00:29:04.366 --> 00:29:07.446
I'm not going to waste the board's time today on the personal attacks contained in

568
00:29:07.486 --> 00:29:10.986
the agenda item. The security cameras referenced in the

569
00:29:12.526 --> 00:29:15.446
agenda item were installed for a good reason.

570
00:29:15.486 --> 00:29:17.246
The choices they captured on video,

571
00:29:18.106 --> 00:29:22.046
rock-throwing, paintballs, lasers, was a surprise to

572
00:29:22.086 --> 00:29:22.206
me.

573
00:29:23.186 --> 00:29:26.606
I didn't think people would react that way to

574
00:29:26.686 --> 00:29:30.286
a deed compliance hearing. The

575
00:29:30.326 --> 00:29:34.206
behavior really unmasks the victim narrative that was in that

576
00:29:34.246 --> 00:29:34.946
four-page

577
00:29:36.226 --> 00:29:36.966
agenda item.

578
00:29:38.646 --> 00:29:41.926
Security camera footage and other incidents like these are being handled by the

579
00:29:41.966 --> 00:29:45.886
proper authorities. They'll be a matter of public record once the investigation is

580
00:29:45.926 --> 00:29:48.766
complete. So I'm going to leave that exactly where it is.

581
00:29:49.626 --> 00:29:53.026
I choose to focus the rest of my time here on the stormwater swale, its effects on

582
00:29:53.046 --> 00:29:53.686
the neighborhood.

583
00:29:54.606 --> 00:29:58.516
The swale and the easement of 4540 are shared infrastructure that

584
00:29:58.566 --> 00:30:02.326
many of us own Perlman Way, even if the homeowner doesn't like it.

585
00:30:03.166 --> 00:30:06.666
It's no different in principle from other utilities in that easement.

586
00:30:07.486 --> 00:30:10.866
A homeowner would never be allowed to lower the voltage in the neighborhood's

587
00:30:10.926 --> 00:30:14.786
electric service or limit internet connectivity simply

588
00:30:14.826 --> 00:30:17.086
because the lines are in their backyard.

589
00:30:18.375 --> 00:30:21.666
The issue has dire consequences beyond Perlman

590
00:30:21.726 --> 00:30:23.886
Way and beyond Beluna.

591
00:30:25.366 --> 00:30:29.306
The board's response will dictate whether an engineered swale easement in

592
00:30:29.326 --> 00:30:32.686
the villages must remain functional as designed and permitted,

593
00:30:33.336 --> 00:30:36.906
or whether individual homeowners can choose to replace the swale on their

594
00:30:36.926 --> 00:30:40.856
property with their version of what a stormwater swale should

595
00:30:40.886 --> 00:30:44.530
look like and their private drain system.Imagine

596
00:30:44.770 --> 00:30:48.650
the chaos that you'll unleash if this becomes the

597
00:30:48.690 --> 00:30:51.810
reference case for how the village's CDD handles stormwater

598
00:30:51.910 --> 00:30:55.510
cases. As the board is aware, the sole remaining

599
00:30:55.530 --> 00:30:58.490
obstruction is at 4540 Pearlman Way,

600
00:30:59.390 --> 00:31:03.209
which the report identifies as the ultimate choke point.

601
00:31:03.230 --> 00:31:06.430
In practical terms, this is a documented system failure

602
00:31:07.170 --> 00:31:08.870
of the shared stormwater system.

603
00:31:09.760 --> 00:31:12.560
There's some Florida statutes that give you direct and clear

604
00:31:12.610 --> 00:31:16.279
authority and responsibility to maintain that stormwater system,

605
00:31:17.150 --> 00:31:21.120
and even Chapter 373 depends on

606
00:31:21.150 --> 00:31:23.790
these systems functioning in accordance to approved standards.

607
00:31:24.750 --> 00:31:28.110
I'm not asking the board to accept responsibility for the homeowners' choices.

608
00:31:29.190 --> 00:31:32.410
The deed compliance staff could never have anticipated the scale and

609
00:31:32.470 --> 00:31:35.930
complexity of the many violations at 4540.

610
00:31:36.610 --> 00:31:39.770
What I'm asking the board to do is act within its responsibility for district

611
00:31:39.870 --> 00:31:41.710
shared stormwater infrastructure.

612
00:31:42.550 --> 00:31:46.530
Now that a documented system failure has been identified by a civil engineering

613
00:31:46.610 --> 00:31:46.870
firm,

614
00:31:47.810 --> 00:31:50.950
the responsibility for stormwater cannot and should not be

615
00:31:50.990 --> 00:31:53.390
subordinated to the choices of a homeowner,

616
00:31:54.210 --> 00:31:57.770
nor should the issue be tossed back to the neighborhood to solve.

617
00:31:58.340 --> 00:32:02.200
We expect the district to handle shared infrastructure issues and are frankly

618
00:32:02.230 --> 00:32:04.970
dumbfounded as to why this is even an issue.

619
00:32:06.390 --> 00:32:10.290
If the board believes that it lacks the authority

620
00:32:10.350 --> 00:32:14.010
under Chapter 190 or the board declines to act, then I

621
00:32:14.030 --> 00:32:17.210
respectfully ask that decision be clearly on the record.

622
00:32:18.270 --> 00:32:21.950
You have effectively green-lighted any unauthorized stormwater drainage

623
00:32:22.010 --> 00:32:25.570
system and ceded your authority to individual homeowners within the

624
00:32:25.610 --> 00:32:26.090
villages.

625
00:32:27.290 --> 00:32:31.190
In summary, district council has issued a demand letter to fix the swale in

626
00:32:31.250 --> 00:32:35.150
January. You have a civil engineer's report from March that

627
00:32:35.230 --> 00:32:35.890
you paid for

628
00:32:36.830 --> 00:32:38.830
that identifies the ultimate choke point.

629
00:32:39.450 --> 00:32:43.050
The report vindicates and validates the district property

630
00:32:43.110 --> 00:32:46.190
manager's conclusion in February that the swale modifications are

631
00:32:46.270 --> 00:32:49.850
unauthorized, and you have a chronology in your agenda packet that

632
00:32:49.930 --> 00:32:53.620
demonstrates the homeowners have slow-walked every attempt to become

633
00:32:53.690 --> 00:32:57.630
compliant since 2023. All of the check boxes are complete.

634
00:32:59.270 --> 00:33:01.110
Respectfully, please

635
00:33:01.950 --> 00:33:05.130
deliberate, pass a motion today to compel the

636
00:33:05.140 --> 00:33:09.060
homeowner to submit a written plan, require full restoration

637
00:33:09.090 --> 00:33:12.960
of the drainage easement to its designed and permitted condition, and

638
00:33:13.010 --> 00:33:16.310
verify compliance through staff or engineering resources.

639
00:33:19.230 --> 00:33:23.220
Thank you. At this time, I'm going to refer to you and let you

640
00:33:23.250 --> 00:33:23.570
handle this.

641
00:33:24.110 --> 00:33:26.670
Yeah.

642
00:33:28.350 --> 00:33:28.360
Okay.

643
00:33:28.360 --> 00:33:28.360
Yeah.

644
00:33:28.410 --> 00:33:30.750
It's up to you if you would like us to respond to the board.

645
00:33:30.819 --> 00:33:32.910
Yes. I'd like a response from you guys.

646
00:33:33.050 --> 00:33:35.830
So from a deed compliance standpoint, everything is

647
00:33:37.190 --> 00:33:39.970
complete and moving forward like your system works.

648
00:33:40.150 --> 00:33:44.130
When it comes to the stormwater swale, you elected

649
00:33:44.170 --> 00:33:47.890
to have an engineer do a study, which did indicate that there

650
00:33:47.950 --> 00:33:51.690
was modifications to the swale, and you had two

651
00:33:51.770 --> 00:33:55.730
options at that point. One was you could take it under district, and

652
00:33:55.790 --> 00:33:58.130
you could require that it be changed, and Mr.

653
00:33:58.350 --> 00:34:01.790
Briones talked to you about different options as far as what that would

654
00:34:01.830 --> 00:34:05.730
potentially take. The second option is to determine that it

655
00:34:05.790 --> 00:34:09.350
is not impacting the entire district's stormwater management

656
00:34:09.430 --> 00:34:12.870
system and allow the homeowners to work it out amongst

657
00:34:12.890 --> 00:34:16.670
themselves civilly. At that meeting, that is what you elected to

658
00:34:16.770 --> 00:34:20.720
do, and you determined that you did not want to move forward with having

659
00:34:20.770 --> 00:34:24.650
a further study done or requiring that the

660
00:34:24.690 --> 00:34:28.310
property owners have a study done to determine how it needs to be

661
00:34:28.370 --> 00:34:32.281
fixed. That is the last conversation that the board has had on

662
00:34:32.310 --> 00:34:33.091
this matter.

663
00:34:35.511 --> 00:34:36.611
I think it brings me to this.

664
00:34:38.170 --> 00:34:40.890
And I reviewed the minutes, and that's exactly right.

665
00:34:41.091 --> 00:34:41.310
Yes.

666
00:34:42.170 --> 00:34:44.490
That's an accurate depiction of what was discussed.

667
00:34:44.611 --> 00:34:48.470
In my memory, there was one kind of lingering issue

668
00:34:48.531 --> 00:34:52.230
with the engineering report and it seemed to bring other factors in

669
00:34:53.810 --> 00:34:54.970
that may have played into it.

670
00:34:55.790 --> 00:34:55.970
So

671
00:34:57.130 --> 00:35:01.010
again, I think that council will know legally

672
00:35:01.030 --> 00:35:04.930
what we can and can't do, and then we'll guide accordingly and then bring it to

673
00:35:04.970 --> 00:35:05.370
the board.

674
00:35:06.130 --> 00:35:09.310
So we did go through that at last month's meeting, and you decided not to take any

675
00:35:09.410 --> 00:35:09.750
action.

676
00:35:09.890 --> 00:35:10.030
Right.

677
00:35:10.830 --> 00:35:12.950
We reviewed the report and agreed that the report

678
00:35:13.910 --> 00:35:17.830
didn't quite have enough information, but in order to get a more complete report,

679
00:35:17.910 --> 00:35:20.090
it was going to cost this board too much money.

680
00:35:20.130 --> 00:35:23.330
And so at that point, you decided we're going to let the property owners deal with

681
00:35:23.370 --> 00:35:26.730
it themselves. We're not going to require that anything be done further at this

682
00:35:26.750 --> 00:35:27.050
point.

683
00:35:29.190 --> 00:35:32.030
I agree with that. Any other comments from the board?

684
00:35:32.450 --> 00:35:32.710
Mm-mm.

685
00:35:36.050 --> 00:35:39.590
So if there's still some concern, if this board is still

686
00:35:39.630 --> 00:35:40.810
considering possibly

687
00:35:42.190 --> 00:35:45.850
obtaining another report, expending additional funds, potentially requiring

688
00:35:45.890 --> 00:35:49.610
improvements, then at this point, there's no sense in negotiating

689
00:35:50.570 --> 00:35:54.430
a settlement or compromise of the amount of money you'd have to do because in

690
00:35:54.490 --> 00:35:56.330
doing so, you'll be essentially closing out this

691
00:35:57.470 --> 00:35:57.850
case.

692
00:36:02.350 --> 00:36:05.720
As I recall, we were talking about $25,000-

693
00:36:06.130 --> 00:36:06.140
Yeah

694
00:36:06.190 --> 00:36:07.510
... for an additional report?

695
00:36:07.970 --> 00:36:08.690
Yes.

696
00:36:08.750 --> 00:36:08.910
Yeah.

697
00:36:09.170 --> 00:36:10.320
We spent, what, five already?

698
00:36:11.070 --> 00:36:13.450
Yes. Somewhere in that neighborhood.

699
00:36:13.510 --> 00:36:16.730
And what I think Mr. Briones is saying is if you

700
00:36:17.910 --> 00:36:21.900
are going to determine that this is a potential district stormwater issue

701
00:36:22.430 --> 00:36:26.190
and you are potentially going to want to have that report, then you don't want him

702
00:36:26.230 --> 00:36:30.180
to negotiate the fees yet because that is something that

703
00:36:30.270 --> 00:36:33.750
if an additional engineer's report determined that it was in fact the

704
00:36:33.770 --> 00:36:37.630
modifications by that specific property owner, then that would be part of what you

705
00:36:37.650 --> 00:36:40.270
would lump in as far as charging them for that.

706
00:36:40.950 --> 00:36:43.990
And as far as the court case is concerned, if you think about what a judge would

707
00:36:44.050 --> 00:36:44.570
think about

708
00:36:45.462 --> 00:36:49.362
... this board decides to negotiate and settle an issue, and then at some

709
00:36:49.382 --> 00:36:52.642
later point try and bring that issue back, I think that'd be a problem.

710
00:36:52.742 --> 00:36:52.842
So

711
00:36:53.902 --> 00:36:57.442
if you're still thinking you may want them to do something, now is not the time to

712
00:36:57.462 --> 00:37:01.222
negotiate any sort of settlement or negotiate any fines or

713
00:37:01.302 --> 00:37:01.761
costs.

714
00:37:02.582 --> 00:37:04.362
And if we don't, we just wait?

715
00:37:05.902 --> 00:37:05.952
Correct.

716
00:37:05.952 --> 00:37:06.602
To see what happens?

717
00:37:06.982 --> 00:37:07.302
Correct.

718
00:37:11.582 --> 00:37:15.202
Someone has to make a determination somewhere along the line whether or not there

719
00:37:15.262 --> 00:37:18.682
is an issue here that we have to get involved with, don't we?

720
00:37:18.842 --> 00:37:19.222
I mean, as a board-

721
00:37:19.242 --> 00:37:22.222
The other thing is, if you recall, the property owner did say last month that they

722
00:37:22.262 --> 00:37:25.002
would do what they needed to do if this board asked them to make some changes, they

723
00:37:25.042 --> 00:37:25.462
would do it.

724
00:37:26.442 --> 00:37:28.302
Of course, that can be part of the settlement as well.

725
00:37:29.822 --> 00:37:29.982
Mm-hmm.

726
00:37:30.072 --> 00:37:33.582
The motion was have counsel settle the fees

727
00:37:34.462 --> 00:37:38.282
that are due, but as part of that settlement, if you want to say, "Well, last

728
00:37:38.342 --> 00:37:41.242
month you said you would bring it back, you'd install that swale.

729
00:37:42.222 --> 00:37:45.622
We'll reduce the fines. This is all we really want, but we do want you to do that,"

730
00:37:46.802 --> 00:37:47.762
then you can do that as well.

731
00:37:48.722 --> 00:37:52.142
I'm in favor of going that way with it and have him

732
00:37:52.182 --> 00:37:54.361
negotiate what needs to be done.

733
00:37:54.942 --> 00:37:55.382
I agree.

734
00:37:55.522 --> 00:37:59.362
Which would include restoration, if there is to be made, to the correct

735
00:37:59.402 --> 00:38:01.982
plan. We can just say, "You have to comply with this," or whatever.

736
00:38:02.222 --> 00:38:02.372
Right.

737
00:38:03.482 --> 00:38:05.242
Like you said, I don't want to go in there blind-

738
00:38:05.622 --> 00:38:05.942
Yes

739
00:38:05.952 --> 00:38:07.722
... and get blindsided later.

740
00:38:08.382 --> 00:38:08.762
I think-

741
00:38:08.902 --> 00:38:10.512
The gentleman that just spoke, the Mr.

742
00:38:10.682 --> 00:38:14.332
Defernando, implies that we have to do X, Y, and

743
00:38:14.442 --> 00:38:14.682
Z,

744
00:38:15.562 --> 00:38:19.362
may or may not be the case. But I think that if we

745
00:38:19.442 --> 00:38:23.422
are going to try to settle this matter, it would make sense to do that.

746
00:38:23.562 --> 00:38:27.542
We can either just let it sit there and do nothing and wait till something happens.

747
00:38:28.372 --> 00:38:31.262
I don't know what that is. Or we can attempt to say, "Hey,

748
00:38:32.362 --> 00:38:33.442
we can settle this matter."

749
00:38:34.362 --> 00:38:38.162
And part of the settlement could be, I believe, that you have to be in compliance

750
00:38:38.222 --> 00:38:38.762
with whatever

751
00:38:39.602 --> 00:38:43.562
the requirements are for the transportation of water or drainage or

752
00:38:43.602 --> 00:38:44.222
whatever it is.

753
00:38:45.562 --> 00:38:48.822
I believe the report had two options, but certainly the

754
00:38:49.302 --> 00:38:52.822
replacement of the swale was the preferred option.

755
00:38:52.942 --> 00:38:56.742
The other option had to do, I think, with a four-inch drain or something like that.

756
00:38:56.882 --> 00:38:57.052
Yeah, change the drain.

757
00:38:57.052 --> 00:38:57.632
Yeah, right. Install drainages, which-

758
00:38:57.662 --> 00:39:01.242
At the end of the day, though, I'll do whatever I need to do,

759
00:39:01.722 --> 00:39:05.142
and work with Supervisor Montalvo, but at the end of the day, any

760
00:39:05.342 --> 00:39:07.702
recommendation for settlement has to be approved by this board.

761
00:39:07.762 --> 00:39:10.942
So if we come back to you and say, "We agreed to

762
00:39:11.042 --> 00:39:14.862
$1,000, and they're going to bring the property back to the way it was before," you

763
00:39:14.882 --> 00:39:18.002
can say yes or no. Or, "We agreed to 1,000, but they're not going to do anything,"

764
00:39:18.082 --> 00:39:21.402
you can say yes or no. It doesn't get done without board approval.

765
00:39:22.102 --> 00:39:22.422
Well, the-

766
00:39:22.782 --> 00:39:24.382
One more point of clarity. Sorry, go ahead.

767
00:39:24.502 --> 00:39:26.062
No, go ahead.

768
00:39:26.142 --> 00:39:28.722
If we're responsible for the swale,

769
00:39:29.902 --> 00:39:30.742
and we do nothing,

770
00:39:31.862 --> 00:39:32.882
and something happens,

771
00:39:34.302 --> 00:39:38.122
we finally get it arranged, and we have damage, are we responsible for the damage

772
00:39:38.132 --> 00:39:38.562
that's done?

773
00:39:39.222 --> 00:39:41.352
Possibly, and that's the issue. The issue is-

774
00:39:41.371 --> 00:39:41.371
Yes

775
00:39:41.371 --> 00:39:45.122
... the report you have doesn't provide you with the information you

776
00:39:45.142 --> 00:39:49.122
really need. To get that report, you may pay 25 grand, and it tells you

777
00:39:49.162 --> 00:39:52.882
the same thing. That's the difficult part.

778
00:39:52.922 --> 00:39:56.802
The difficult part is determining whether the changes that were made will

779
00:39:56.862 --> 00:39:58.382
have a substantial impact on the

780
00:40:00.682 --> 00:40:02.562
infrastructure in the system, the drainage system.

781
00:40:02.632 --> 00:40:04.422
Okay. Since if we're going to have the

782
00:40:05.362 --> 00:40:09.282
right to approve or disapprove, then I'm also in favor of me sitting down

783
00:40:09.302 --> 00:40:13.142
with the homeowner, and if part of it can be to return the swale to the way it

784
00:40:13.182 --> 00:40:15.142
was, if they accept that.

785
00:40:15.162 --> 00:40:15.562
Fourth time.

786
00:40:15.602 --> 00:40:16.402
I don't think it's-

787
00:40:17.562 --> 00:40:17.931
I guess we need two copies of that.

788
00:40:17.962 --> 00:40:21.642
If somebody's done something that forces us to be liable for something that we

789
00:40:21.682 --> 00:40:24.522
shouldn't be liable for, in my opinion, it's got to be fixed.

790
00:40:25.042 --> 00:40:28.462
And if I recall from the report, there were actually two properties that were-

791
00:40:29.362 --> 00:40:30.452
And that was my point before. Yeah

792
00:40:30.452 --> 00:40:33.431
... So even if they correct it, there's still another property, from what I

793
00:40:33.442 --> 00:40:37.302
understand, that would also need to take action for it to be healthy and drain the

794
00:40:37.322 --> 00:40:38.002
way it's supposed to.

795
00:40:38.382 --> 00:40:42.162
And I believe that that property owner did already take action and return the

796
00:40:42.262 --> 00:40:43.262
swale back to how it was.

797
00:40:43.322 --> 00:40:44.392
Right. Okay. So then that takes care of the other piece.

798
00:40:44.392 --> 00:40:47.122
Yeah, and we have a letter to that effect. Yeah.

799
00:40:47.582 --> 00:40:47.742
So

800
00:40:49.062 --> 00:40:51.942
I'm with you, Dale. Let's take a look at it.

801
00:40:52.502 --> 00:40:56.322
Let's talk to them. Let's find out what we can come up with, and then

802
00:40:56.362 --> 00:40:59.782
bring it to the board, and then we can have the discussion at the next board

803
00:40:59.842 --> 00:41:02.101
meeting or next time we get on this thing.

804
00:41:02.382 --> 00:41:02.651
That works.

805
00:41:02.651 --> 00:41:02.901
From this side.

806
00:41:03.222 --> 00:41:03.601
Yes, sir.

807
00:41:04.742 --> 00:41:05.822
I need a motion for this.

808
00:41:06.302 --> 00:41:07.362
No, that's part of the motion.

809
00:41:07.502 --> 00:41:08.432
That's part of the motion. Yeah.

810
00:41:08.442 --> 00:41:11.862
The negotiation now will take into consideration the board's concern with

811
00:41:11.902 --> 00:41:13.892
the swale and whether

812
00:41:14.742 --> 00:41:17.782
the property owners are still in the same position they were last month, where they

813
00:41:17.822 --> 00:41:20.502
said they would return it to the way it was if they needed to.

814
00:41:20.902 --> 00:41:22.102
All right. Thank you.

815
00:41:22.342 --> 00:41:23.522
Great. Thank you.

816
00:41:23.562 --> 00:41:23.862
Thank you.

817
00:41:24.282 --> 00:41:25.482
Can I say something?

818
00:41:25.562 --> 00:41:25.762
Yes.

819
00:41:26.222 --> 00:41:27.902
I'm the property owner he's talking about.

820
00:41:29.062 --> 00:41:31.742
Your report said, if there's a flooding problem...

821
00:41:32.042 --> 00:41:34.282
Your report couldn't even say there was a flooding.

822
00:41:34.762 --> 00:41:38.702
Your engineer said, "If there's a flooding, it's temporary and very

823
00:41:38.782 --> 00:41:42.442
short-lived." And I can tell you, it rained once, and our street

824
00:41:42.542 --> 00:41:45.742
flooded. So a certain amount of rain, everything can flood a little bit.

825
00:41:46.862 --> 00:41:49.522
But the report did say, and watch out, there were two properties.

826
00:41:49.862 --> 00:41:50.642
One of them was his.

827
00:41:51.442 --> 00:41:55.092
And I'd also like to add, he stood up here and said, "I'm throwing rocks and doing

828
00:41:55.122 --> 00:41:59.042
something with a paintball gun. You'll all be part of a slander land." I just

829
00:41:59.062 --> 00:42:01.642
got slandered. I couldn't throw a rock from here to there.

830
00:42:01.942 --> 00:42:03.342
I've had my right shoulder replaced.

831
00:42:03.802 --> 00:42:06.122
So he can't stand there and tell you I'm...

832
00:42:06.542 --> 00:42:09.942
First of all, what's rock-throwing got to do with what we're talking about?

833
00:42:10.862 --> 00:42:13.222
And as far as paintball guns, I don't own a paintball gun.

834
00:42:13.542 --> 00:42:17.482
I did happen to own the largest paintball arena in the country, but that was 10

835
00:42:17.502 --> 00:42:20.942
years ago. And technically, I never owned a paintball gun then, the company did.

836
00:42:21.182 --> 00:42:24.602
And I never bought one to Florida. You stand up here and let him

837
00:42:24.642 --> 00:42:28.582
accuse me and Debbie of a lot of things, and you guys

838
00:42:28.622 --> 00:42:30.942
reacted by getting a civil engineer coming out.

839
00:42:31.262 --> 00:42:34.182
When they came out and said, "Well, there's really not a problem here." But he did

840
00:42:34.242 --> 00:42:37.462
say there's a problem with his property, and he stood up here and just pointed a

841
00:42:37.522 --> 00:42:41.361
finger at us so much. But your report says, if there's a flooding

842
00:42:41.442 --> 00:42:43.742
problem, it's very minor and very temporary.

843
00:42:45.134 --> 00:42:46.394
Do you still want to sit-

844
00:42:46.514 --> 00:42:47.554
We'll keep working with you.

845
00:42:47.614 --> 00:42:47.843
My question-

846
00:42:47.854 --> 00:42:49.614
We want to give you that attitude. We want to work with you.

847
00:42:49.694 --> 00:42:49.984
Yeah, my question-

848
00:42:49.984 --> 00:42:51.074
But I can't let him slander me.

849
00:42:51.394 --> 00:42:55.074
I get it. And that's a separate issue, but my question here as a board

850
00:42:55.154 --> 00:42:58.594
member is, are you willing to sit down with us and negotiate this thing?

851
00:42:58.854 --> 00:43:00.313
Absolutely. We've already had a meeting.

852
00:43:00.324 --> 00:43:00.534
Okay, then let's do it.

853
00:43:00.573 --> 00:43:02.904
We've had a meeting with your engineers to talk to them about it.

854
00:43:02.924 --> 00:43:03.594
All right. Let's do it.

855
00:43:04.074 --> 00:43:05.674
We just got to sit down and bring them in.

856
00:43:05.954 --> 00:43:08.434
But again, they said there's almost not a flooding problem.

857
00:43:08.794 --> 00:43:11.714
The flooding problem's on the other property. They're holding the water up.

858
00:43:12.774 --> 00:43:13.034
All right.

859
00:43:13.294 --> 00:43:14.294
And that's his property.

860
00:43:14.694 --> 00:43:14.904
Thank you.

861
00:43:14.924 --> 00:43:17.113
But he stands up here and gets to accuse us of everything.

862
00:43:18.174 --> 00:43:19.134
I appreciate your time.

863
00:43:19.394 --> 00:43:19.654
Thank you.

864
00:43:20.134 --> 00:43:20.604
Thanks, Keith.

865
00:43:23.294 --> 00:43:25.334
That was a little hard.

866
00:43:27.854 --> 00:43:28.574
Old business.

867
00:43:29.074 --> 00:43:31.534
Yes, sir. The first item was for Mr.

868
00:43:31.754 --> 00:43:35.214
Briones to forward letters to property owners with an outstanding fine

869
00:43:35.254 --> 00:43:38.214
balance, and Old Business does indicate that is complete.

870
00:43:39.224 --> 00:43:43.174
The second item was to forward all of the original applications

871
00:43:43.274 --> 00:43:47.254
for 4540 Pearlman Way, so that has been complete

872
00:43:47.314 --> 00:43:47.734
as well.

873
00:43:48.794 --> 00:43:52.054
The last two items, you have updates on your agenda.

874
00:43:52.114 --> 00:43:55.634
One was a missing bench at Spanish Moss, and the second was a

875
00:43:55.714 --> 00:43:58.774
review for golf course conditions in your geographical area.

876
00:43:59.794 --> 00:44:02.934
Those updates are included on the agenda, and the email that was forwarded to the

877
00:44:03.034 --> 00:44:05.854
board is also attached for the residents' benefit.

878
00:44:07.774 --> 00:44:08.214
Thank you.

879
00:44:09.774 --> 00:44:11.574
Any other comments? Moving on.

880
00:44:13.254 --> 00:44:14.174
District manager.

881
00:44:15.774 --> 00:44:19.414
Yes, sir. The only item that I have on district manager reports

882
00:44:19.514 --> 00:44:23.114
is to introduce Ms. Allison Brennan, who is going to go

883
00:44:23.194 --> 00:44:27.114
through some exciting changes that is happening through our community relations

884
00:44:27.174 --> 00:44:27.774
department.

885
00:44:29.014 --> 00:44:29.414
Mm-hmm.

886
00:44:39.704 --> 00:44:43.494
Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Allison Brennan.

887
00:44:43.554 --> 00:44:47.494
I'm the community relations coordinator, and I

888
00:44:47.614 --> 00:44:51.534
am here today to talk to you about a significant step forward in how we're

889
00:44:51.574 --> 00:44:55.494
going to communicate with our residents with the launch of Sailthru, our

890
00:44:55.514 --> 00:44:57.254
new e-notification platform.

891
00:45:00.174 --> 00:45:03.294
I'd like to start with a quick overview of what the platform does.

892
00:45:03.714 --> 00:45:07.594
At its core, Sailthru allows us to centralize communications across all

893
00:45:07.694 --> 00:45:09.654
district departments into one system.

894
00:45:10.334 --> 00:45:12.694
That creates consistency, improves

895
00:45:13.514 --> 00:45:17.454
coordination, and ensures residents receive clear and timely information.

896
00:45:18.314 --> 00:45:20.834
One of the key benefits is targeted outreach.

897
00:45:21.334 --> 00:45:25.174
We can send messages to specific groups by district, service area,

898
00:45:25.734 --> 00:45:29.154
or impacted residents, rather than sending broad,

899
00:45:29.314 --> 00:45:31.664
one-size-fits-all communication.

900
00:45:32.414 --> 00:45:36.094
It also supports both scheduled and real-time notifications, such as

901
00:45:36.174 --> 00:45:40.134
boil water notices, while giving us engagement data so we can

902
00:45:40.194 --> 00:45:42.134
continually improve how we communicate.

903
00:45:44.354 --> 00:45:48.114
To make sure this was implemented effectively, we followed a structured rollout

904
00:45:48.174 --> 00:45:48.694
approach.

905
00:45:50.934 --> 00:45:54.224
We approached implementation in phases, started with defining

906
00:45:54.274 --> 00:45:58.114
requirements and building workflows, then moving into data

907
00:45:58.134 --> 00:46:00.614
preparation, testing, and staff training.

908
00:46:01.394 --> 00:46:05.054
From there, we're going to conduct a limited rollout that will start next

909
00:46:05.114 --> 00:46:09.054
Monday to monitor performance, address any early

910
00:46:09.134 --> 00:46:12.834
issues, and refine the system before full implementation.

911
00:46:13.754 --> 00:46:17.714
This phased approach ensures stability

912
00:46:17.724 --> 00:46:19.114
and long-term success.

913
00:46:21.134 --> 00:46:24.634
With the system in place, our focus shifts to what we want to achieve with

914
00:46:24.694 --> 00:46:27.094
it. Our objectives are straightforward.

915
00:46:27.494 --> 00:46:31.434
First, we want to improve clarity and consistency so residents can easily

916
00:46:31.494 --> 00:46:33.204
understand and act on information.

917
00:46:34.074 --> 00:46:36.844
Second, we're going to shift to a proactive communication,

918
00:46:38.714 --> 00:46:42.694
making sure residents are informed ahead of time rather than after the fact.

919
00:46:43.274 --> 00:46:47.114
And third, we're going to establish a modern, scalable communication framework

920
00:46:47.123 --> 00:46:48.834
that supports long-term growth.

921
00:46:51.694 --> 00:46:55.614
To support this, we've also introduced a more structured communication cadence.

922
00:46:57.474 --> 00:46:59.934
We've created a predictable rhythm for communication.

923
00:47:00.134 --> 00:47:04.054
Residents will receive a what's happening update on Mondays focused on events

924
00:47:04.094 --> 00:47:08.074
and community activities. On Thursday, the district bulletin will provide

925
00:47:08.134 --> 00:47:10.434
a more targeted operational update.

926
00:47:11.094 --> 00:47:14.974
In addition, quarterly publications will highlight key departments such

927
00:47:15.014 --> 00:47:18.794
as district property management, public safety, community watch, and

928
00:47:18.854 --> 00:47:22.154
golf operations. This consistency helps set

929
00:47:22.194 --> 00:47:24.554
expectations and build trust with residents.

930
00:47:26.634 --> 00:47:30.274
Beyond delivery, this platform also gives us valuable insight into

931
00:47:30.314 --> 00:47:30.974
performance.

932
00:47:32.074 --> 00:47:35.814
Sailthru provides visibility and engagement such as open

933
00:47:35.874 --> 00:47:38.634
rates, click-through rates, and audience trends over time.

934
00:47:39.214 --> 00:47:43.004
It also ensures consistent communication across all districts and improves

935
00:47:43.034 --> 00:47:45.594
coordination during routine updates and emergency

936
00:47:45.634 --> 00:47:49.454
situations. From a governance perspective, this allows us

937
00:47:49.514 --> 00:47:53.124
to provide standardized reporting to leadership and board, supporting

938
00:47:53.174 --> 00:47:56.494
transparency and informed decision-making.

939
00:47:56.534 --> 00:48:00.354
And ultimately, this leads to long-term growth for the organization.

940
00:48:02.234 --> 00:48:05.474
This platform strengthens trust by delivering clear, consistent

941
00:48:05.574 --> 00:48:09.254
communication and supports scalable growth as the district

942
00:48:09.294 --> 00:48:12.854
continues to evolve, and it provides the data needed to guide

943
00:48:12.894 --> 00:48:16.374
strategic decisions. In short, this is about building a more

944
00:48:16.654 --> 00:48:20.574
efficient, transparent, and trusted communication system for the future.

945
00:48:22.654 --> 00:48:26.484
Thank you, guys, and I am here if you have any questions, and I am happy

946
00:48:26.574 --> 00:48:27.394
to answer them.

947
00:48:28.114 --> 00:48:30.034
You're saying it's going to roll out next week?

948
00:48:30.314 --> 00:48:33.154
It is going to start on Monday with a phased rollout approach.

949
00:48:33.594 --> 00:48:37.024
So we will be sending a set amount each

950
00:48:37.194 --> 00:48:41.094
day and then seeing how that goes, and then we're either going to slow

951
00:48:41.114 --> 00:48:44.494
down or we're going to keep that same cadence up on the next day.

952
00:48:44.634 --> 00:48:46.594
So we'll be keeping a really close eye on that.

953
00:48:47.002 --> 00:48:49.982
So to the resident's email address is where it's going to go to?

954
00:48:50.342 --> 00:48:53.402
Correct. So anybody that is currently signed up to receive an

955
00:48:53.442 --> 00:48:56.882
e-notification, we have consolidated those lists

956
00:48:57.022 --> 00:48:57.642
into

957
00:48:59.642 --> 00:49:03.602
different sections. And so those will go out per section, depending on

958
00:49:03.622 --> 00:49:05.242
what the residents are signed up for.

959
00:49:05.442 --> 00:49:06.402
It's actually going to be

960
00:49:07.382 --> 00:49:11.322
the annual report will be going out, so that's something that kind of pertains

961
00:49:11.382 --> 00:49:14.781
to everyone. As you guys know, the annual report recently came out.

962
00:49:14.882 --> 00:49:18.022
And legally, we have to have something that kind of applies to everybody that

963
00:49:18.102 --> 00:49:21.892
signed up. So we figured that would be a great way to get the annual report out

964
00:49:21.922 --> 00:49:22.642
there as well.

965
00:49:24.342 --> 00:49:24.872
Any questions?

966
00:49:24.872 --> 00:49:25.762
Any other questions?

967
00:49:26.302 --> 00:49:27.562
No. Thank you.

968
00:49:27.842 --> 00:49:28.722
All right. Thank you.

969
00:49:28.732 --> 00:49:29.122
Thank you. Very good.

970
00:49:34.642 --> 00:49:36.082
Moving on. District Council.

971
00:49:38.742 --> 00:49:42.542
Just one report. There have been requests recently in

972
00:49:42.602 --> 00:49:45.712
some districts, and possibly in this district, but we're bringing it to you even if

973
00:49:45.722 --> 00:49:49.442
there haven't been, for reduction or waiver of fines

974
00:49:49.522 --> 00:49:52.882
for certain code enforcement or deed compliance cases.

975
00:49:53.602 --> 00:49:57.382
And in those cases, there's no real process since you use the hearing

976
00:49:57.442 --> 00:50:01.062
master who's to hear those requests.

977
00:50:01.092 --> 00:50:04.022
So I guess the question for this district, along with some of the other districts

978
00:50:04.062 --> 00:50:07.982
that also use the hearing master, is do you want those to come to you?

979
00:50:08.542 --> 00:50:12.182
Extensions of time, anytime someone wants to extend the time to

980
00:50:12.222 --> 00:50:16.062
comply with a deed compliance matter because of one reason or the

981
00:50:16.122 --> 00:50:19.922
other, medical condition or whatever the case may be, do you want to hear those or

982
00:50:19.962 --> 00:50:23.162
do you want your special master to hear those?

983
00:50:23.202 --> 00:50:26.862
If there's a waiver of fines, generally that comes before you as a board.

984
00:50:27.402 --> 00:50:31.082
But in those cases where someone is asking for additional time, or even the waiver

985
00:50:31.102 --> 00:50:33.582
of fines, there's no real process in our rule for that.

986
00:50:34.482 --> 00:50:37.282
With regard to waiver of fines, of course, we would recommend that you make that

987
00:50:37.302 --> 00:50:38.682
decision because it's your budget-

988
00:50:38.722 --> 00:50:38.732
Mm-hmm. Yeah

989
00:50:38.732 --> 00:50:42.542
... and your money. But when it comes to the extension of time, do you

990
00:50:42.602 --> 00:50:46.542
want the hearing master to make that decision, or would you rather

991
00:50:46.602 --> 00:50:46.922
do it?

992
00:50:47.822 --> 00:50:50.642
From a legal standpoint, it would seem to me that the hearing master would make

993
00:50:50.682 --> 00:50:53.822
that decision since they've received all the evidence and already know about the

994
00:50:53.922 --> 00:50:57.702
file and the case. But again, since there's no process currently,

995
00:50:58.282 --> 00:51:00.522
I'm asking this board for direction on that.

996
00:51:00.902 --> 00:51:03.952
I'm in favor of letting the hearing master retain and-

997
00:51:04.222 --> 00:51:04.442
Agree

998
00:51:04.462 --> 00:51:05.922
... control that. We still want to-

999
00:51:06.222 --> 00:51:06.351
I am, too

1000
00:51:06.351 --> 00:51:07.842
... look at the waiver of the fines.

1001
00:51:08.262 --> 00:51:08.562
I agree.

1002
00:51:08.962 --> 00:51:09.342
I agree.

1003
00:51:10.522 --> 00:51:11.982
Okay, so going forward, that's what we'll do.

1004
00:51:12.462 --> 00:51:12.881
Good, thank you.

1005
00:51:13.702 --> 00:51:13.982
Thank you.

1006
00:51:15.962 --> 00:51:16.522
Moving on.

1007
00:51:17.982 --> 00:51:18.522
Project Y.

1008
00:51:19.022 --> 00:51:19.862
Project Y.

1009
00:51:20.942 --> 00:51:23.382
Reasonably benign session this morning.

1010
00:51:24.582 --> 00:51:25.272
One of the things that

1011
00:51:26.782 --> 00:51:29.502
really didn't come up, but I brought it up towards the end.

1012
00:51:29.582 --> 00:51:31.802
I don't know about the rest of the supervisors here,

1013
00:51:32.902 --> 00:51:35.862
and I earlier in the week requested a copy of the new

1014
00:51:37.082 --> 00:51:40.782
water guidelines because it seems like every time I get in a

1015
00:51:40.802 --> 00:51:44.722
golf group, a bowling group, a Publix group, wherever, I get

1016
00:51:44.822 --> 00:51:48.282
asked about when I can water, when I can't water, and everybody's got a different

1017
00:51:48.322 --> 00:51:49.642
opinion. So

1018
00:51:50.562 --> 00:51:53.702
I couldn't find exactly what I thought was the gospel according to-

1019
00:51:54.242 --> 00:51:54.652
Yeah, it was fuzzy

1020
00:51:54.682 --> 00:51:56.112
... the people, so I asked for a copy.

1021
00:51:56.112 --> 00:51:56.622
That's true.

1022
00:51:56.682 --> 00:51:57.392
Yeah. Mm-hmm.

1023
00:51:57.482 --> 00:51:57.822
And

1024
00:51:59.322 --> 00:52:02.202
I think we are going to have somebody from Florida Water.

1025
00:52:02.502 --> 00:52:03.782
Are we not, Terry, at

1026
00:52:05.002 --> 00:52:06.462
Project Y in June?

1027
00:52:07.442 --> 00:52:08.962
I'm not sure. I'd have to confirm that.

1028
00:52:09.042 --> 00:52:12.442
I'm pretty sure that I asked, and I'm pretty sure they told me-

1029
00:52:12.622 --> 00:52:12.822
Okay

1030
00:52:12.962 --> 00:52:13.522
... towards the end.

1031
00:52:14.562 --> 00:52:17.842
Because one of the things, and it was also a little disappointing to me because I

1032
00:52:17.862 --> 00:52:20.662
think it maybe wasn't thought completely through.

1033
00:52:20.702 --> 00:52:23.542
They did say they have to have some kind of

1034
00:52:24.122 --> 00:52:27.862
monitoring or, we won't call it policing, but at least monitoring.

1035
00:52:28.102 --> 00:52:29.541
And Village Watch is doing that.

1036
00:52:30.482 --> 00:52:32.482
I personally think that's a very bad idea.

1037
00:52:34.182 --> 00:52:37.712
I don't want it. The Village Watch does a great job of doing a lot of things,

1038
00:52:38.262 --> 00:52:40.482
but I don't want the

1039
00:52:42.262 --> 00:52:46.062
majority of the congregation here in the villages to turn on

1040
00:52:47.022 --> 00:52:50.362
Village Watch because they're the ones telling me, "Hey, you're going to get a

1041
00:52:50.422 --> 00:52:53.642
letter because you're watering at the wrong time," or whatever.

1042
00:52:54.002 --> 00:52:54.172
But

1043
00:52:55.582 --> 00:52:59.202
I'm trusting if we get to talk to somebody in June, we can get a better

1044
00:52:59.262 --> 00:53:00.642
explanation because

1045
00:53:00.722 --> 00:53:04.222
Village Y, this is

1046
00:53:04.321 --> 00:53:07.941
everything, really. I can't go anywhere that somebody doesn't ask me about the

1047
00:53:07.982 --> 00:53:09.802
water guidelines, and

1048
00:53:10.622 --> 00:53:11.842
I have some concerns, too.

1049
00:53:13.842 --> 00:53:14.122
So

1050
00:53:15.322 --> 00:53:16.122
other than that,

1051
00:53:18.022 --> 00:53:21.222
I don't think there was anything there.

1052
00:53:21.262 --> 00:53:25.102
They did turn down some bids to replace some doors at a

1053
00:53:25.142 --> 00:53:28.222
couple of rec centers because they said it was too high,

1054
00:53:29.342 --> 00:53:29.542
which

1055
00:53:30.402 --> 00:53:32.642
kind of surprised me a little, but they did.

1056
00:53:34.902 --> 00:53:36.502
Other than that, I think it was great.

1057
00:53:37.462 --> 00:53:40.982
Thank you. Any other comments from the board supervisors?

1058
00:53:41.922 --> 00:53:43.282
Do I have a motion to adjourn?

1059
00:53:43.682 --> 00:53:44.282
So moved.

1060
00:53:44.302 --> 00:53:44.622
So moved.

1061
00:53:44.882 --> 00:53:45.642
Do I have a second?

1062
00:53:46.012 --> 00:53:46.012
Second.

1063
00:53:46.722 --> 00:53:47.382
All in favor?

1064
00:53:47.682 --> 00:53:47.882
Aye.

1065
00:53:47.962 --> 00:53:48.382
Aye.

1066
00:53:49.202 --> 00:53:50.232
Meeting adjourned. Thank you.
